top of page

SMFNews: Update: Judge Ends Developer’s Bid for Resort Behind LaSalle County Sharia Vote

Writer: SMF
SMF
22 minutes ago
3 min read
The clock tower and arched windows of the LaSalle County Courthouse beside a navy panel with the headline Judge Ends Bid for Resort Behind LaSalle Sharia Vote
The LaSalle County Courthouse in Ottawa, Illinois. Photo: Bohao Zhao (CC BY 3.0); adapted by SMF.

OTTAWA, Ill. — A federal judge has ruled that a Pennsylvania company has no right to buy the closed Fox River Resort in Sheridan, the property whose possible sale set off LaSalle County’s fight over a resolution denouncing Sharia law. Days later, a county board member said a new resolution is in the works.


SMF reported on Nov. 11 that the LaSalle County Board voted 16-12 on Nov. 2 to rescind that resolution, a month after narrowly approving it, after the county’s own attorney warned that it singled out one religion and would be struck down if challenged in court.


The court ruling


U.S. District Judge John J. Tharp Jr. of the Northern District of Illinois issued a declaratory judgment order on Friday, Nov. 13, on a motion filed by Fox River Resort Club and Silverleaf Resorts LLC, 103.9 WLPO reported. The order found that a mutual termination and release agreement between the resort’s owners and Vairt Inc. is a valid and enforceable contract. It said the purchase and sale agreement between them had been terminated and that Vairt has no right to buy the resort.


The case began in Cook County and was moved to federal court by Vairt in July, according to the court docket. Vairt had also asked the court to send the dispute to arbitration. SMF did not find a public response from Vairt to the ruling as of Nov. 19.


Earlier this year, Vairt told WLPO that there had been much misinformation about its plans and that the property would not be a “Muslim only resort” operating under Sharia law. As of Nov. 19, the company’s website still described a proposed redevelopment of the roughly 165-acre property and its 332 existing residences.


A fact card titled The Fox River Resort ruling and the county board, listing four verified points about the Nov. 13 court order, the Nov. 2 vote and the next board meeting
A summary of the verified facts about the Fox River Resort ruling and the LaSalle County Board.

A new resolution in the works


Board member Ray Gatza, who represents District 9, spoke with WLPO on Monday, Nov. 16, in audio the station posted with its Nov. 17 report. He said the court case had nothing to do with the county board and that he did not want to discuss it as a board member, but that the ruling could open the door to local buyers.


Quote card: LaSalle County Board member Ray Gatza says the ruling opens up an opportunity for local buyers who may take over the resort

— Ray Gatza, LaSalle County Board member, to 103.9 WLPO, Nov. 2026

Gatza also said a new resolution is in the works. Many members “were not completely happy with the way it was written,” he told the station, and the new version would “hopefully be kind of in the middle of things” and aim to “pass a resolution that works for everybody.” He did not describe what the new text would say. At the Oct. 8 meeting, Gatza said he would vote for the original resolution on behalf of his constituents, Shaw Local reported.


Others on the board and in the audience had already asked for a rewrite. On Nov. 2, Michelle Peterson of Defend LaSalle, the group that first pushed for a resolution, asked the board to write a new one combining both versions, and board member Brian Dose said the first step was to rescind the measure “and fix it, and then come back through a committee,” Shaw Local reported. Dose has proposed a committee to address the tax losses from the resort’s closure.


What comes next


The board is scheduled to reconvene on Wednesday, Nov. 25, at 1 p.m., according to its Nov. 2 agenda. SMF did not find a draft of a new resolution or an announced buyer for the resort in public records or local reports as of Nov. 19.


Before the Nov. 2 vote, county attorney Patrick Herrmann told the board that it is unconstitutional for any government, including LaSalle County, to discriminate against a religion, and that naming one faith in the resolution was the problem, Shaw Local reported.


Sources


Comments


Shia Muslim Foundation Logo

Based in the DC Metro Region

Copyright © 2021 by Shia Muslim Foundation
Contact us via email

bottom of page