SMFNews: Fired Muslim Paramedic Sues Baltimore Fire Department Over Beard Policy


BALTIMORE — A former Baltimore City Fire Department paramedic says he was suspended for months and then fired because he would not shave a beard that his Muslim faith requires, according to a federal lawsuit filed in Maryland.
Othmane El Omari, who worked for the department for nearly two years, alleges that it repeatedly denied his requests for a religious accommodation, enforced its grooming policy against him more strictly than against others, and retaliated against him after he filed a federal discrimination complaint, The Baltimore Sun reported. He was fired on March 18, 2026.
The lawsuit was filed Nov. 4 in U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland. It seeks his reinstatement, unspecified damages and changes to the department’s policies on religious accommodations. El Omari has asked for a jury trial. The claims are allegations that have not been tested in court.
A request made on his second day
El Omari joined the department on May 8, 2024, after working for a private emergency medical services company that contracted with the city. The next day, he asked for permission to keep a beard consistent with his religious beliefs, according to the complaint as described by Firehouse, which republished the Sun’s report.
A human resources representative told him an accommodation would not be available until he finished training at the Baltimore City Fire Academy, the suit says. Fearing he would lose his job, he shaved, believing the requirement was temporary. After graduating in November 2024, he renewed his request, and the department denied it, citing its grooming standards.
He then grew a trimmed, goatee-style beard that he believed met his religious obligation without interfering with his safety equipment, and kept it for about six months without incident, according to the complaint. In May 2025, a chief ordered him to shave. He complied, then grew the beard back.

Suspension and the fit test that never happened
On Aug. 9, 2025, a captain warned El Omari that he would be suspended unless he shaved, the suit says. He refused, citing his faith, and the next day he was suspended without pay for 48 work hours for insubordination.
At an Aug. 18 meeting with the department’s human resources director, El Omari again asked for an accommodation and volunteered to take a respirator fit test, which checks whether a breathing mask seals properly against the face. According to the lawsuit, the department never gave him the test and did not consider a less restrictive alternative. He spent about six months on suspension, much of it without pay, before he was fired.
The department’s grooming policy generally bans beards and goatees, but it allows medical exemptions for employees with certain skin conditions. Those employees may keep limited facial hair but are moved to light-duty work, the complaint says. The suit also alleges that other employees, including supervisors, kept facial hair without being disciplined, Hoodline reported.

— OSHA Respiratory Protection Standard, 29 CFR 1910.134(g)(1)(i)
What the safety rule says
The department has said its grooming policy is needed to ensure a proper respirator seal, according to EMS1 reporting cited by Hoodline. The federal rule on that point is strict: under the OSHA respiratory protection standard, employers may not let workers wear tight-fitting respirators if facial hair gets between the mask’s seal and the face or interferes with its valve. Hoodline noted that OSHA guidance also says not all facial hair is disqualifying, and that small, neatly trimmed goatees that do not break the seal usually are not a problem. El Omari’s attorneys argue a fit test could have shown whether his beard affected the seal.
The department has not answered the allegations in public. In a statement to The Baltimore Sun, it said it could not comment on the case because the litigation is pending.

— Baltimore City Fire Department, statement to The Baltimore Sun, November 2026
It is not the department’s only religious-accommodation dispute. Another paramedic, Ariel Rice, has a pending lawsuit alleging the department failed to accommodate his Sabbath and holiday observance and disciplined him for missing shifts that conflicted with his faith, the Sun reported.
Why it matters
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires employers to accommodate an employee’s religious practice unless doing so would cause an undue hardship. In 2023, in Groff v. DeJoy, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled unanimously that an employer must show the burden of an accommodation would result in “substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business,” a higher bar than many courts had applied before.
For many Muslim men, keeping a beard is a religious obligation, and grooming rules in policing, firefighting and emergency medicine have produced conflicts for years. El Omari’s case will test how a fire department weighs those rules, and the safety equipment behind them, against the religious rights of the people who serve the public. The Shia Muslim Foundation will follow the case as it moves through federal court in Maryland.



Comments